On a daily basis at our dog training in Kansas City, I tell people, “My first piece of expert advice is to go home, throw away this retractable leash, and buy a standard 4′-6′ leash.”
Why Are Retractable Leashes Bad For Working With Your Dog?
As I have probably said over a thousand times, “I have never seen a dog in my life that heeled really well, and the owner had a retractable leash.”
Let me say that just one more time in case you missed that, in over 5000+ dogs trained “I have never seen a dog in my life that heeled amazingly well, and the owner had a retractable leash.”
Why this is important is anytime the owner has a retractable leash, there is generally no structure to the walk, whatsoever. Meaning the dog is generally walking ahead, cutting behind, cutting across, pulling out more leash, and just wondering all over the place.
The Biggest Problems I See With Retractable Leashes Are:
-A retractable leash actually teaches your dog to pull, not only does it teach them to pull but it also REWARDS their pulling. What does a retractable leash teach your dog? ”The harder I pull, the more leash I get.” So, your dog is constantly pulling (even though they are at the end) because the leash has conditioned them to learn “by pulling, I keep getting more distance and more leash.”
-It often times leads to improper greetings with other dogs, which can lead to a dog fight or altercation. If another dog is coming while walking your dog on a trail, they can take off running and get 15+ feet momentum to run over to the other dog. This can cause for an improper/uncontrolled greeting where the oncoming dog can interpret wrong, causing an altercation between the two dogs. Then, how do you “reel” your dog back in if there’s an emergency?
-If your dog is a prey-driven animal, and they see a squirrel, cat, rabbit (etc), they can take off running at full speed, the retractable leash gives them 15+ feet of momentum and speed in order to drag you to the ground. We hear these stories on a daily basis at our dog training in Kansas City. If you take the same dog and put them on a 4′-6′ leash, they do not have enough ground in order to get their speed and momentum going which prevents them from being able to pull you down.
-A lot of people have received rope burn from these retractable leashes. Almost every retractable leash has a very thin leash. If this thin leash gets caught around your hand, leg, ankle (etc) and the dog takes off running at a high rate of speed, this cord can cause severe rope burn (to the bone in some cases).
In summary, if you have a retractable leash, do yourself, your arm, and your dog a favor and get rid of it.
You can look at over 400+ of our videos on our YouTube Channel if you want to see what a structured, disciplined, a controlled heel looks like with training.